December 4, 2025

5 Pet Stocking Stuffers for Cats and Dogs

Holiday Gift Guide from Your Hometown Veterinary Team

The holidays are here, which means twinkly lights, cozy evenings, and the perfect excuse to spoil the furry members of the family. If you’re building a stocking for your pet this year, we’ve rounded up safe, vet-approved gift ideas that bring joy without the hazards.

We’ve included links for convenience, but your local pet store or online retailer may carry these items as well. Let’s unwrap the fun!

5 Pet-Safe Stocking Stuffers for Cats

Cardboard Scratchers

Simple, affordable, and endlessly satisfying. Cardboard scratchers let cats express their natural instincts while saving your furniture from their festive flair. They’re also lightweight and easy to replace, making them a perfect low-budget stocking stuffer. Many even come infused with catnip for an extra burst of excitement your cat won’t be able to resist. Grab a three pack from Kitty City XL Wide Corrugate Cat Scratchers for a budget friendly option!

Tunnels

Great for hide-and-seek, pouncing, and full-speed zoomies. Tunnels help cats stay active and mentally stimulated during the winter months. They’re especially wonderful for shy or curious cats who enjoy having a safe spot to dart into. Plus, collapsible tunnels store easily and can be rotated or moved around the house to keep playtime fresh and fun. Cats love hiding, and even more if there’s a crinkle sound involved. Try SmartyKat Crackle Chute Activity Tunnel Cat Toy – A budget-friendly pick with a crinkle interior that adds an extra sensory layer to play — great for hiding, pouncing, and “sneak-attack” fun.

Wand Toys

Wand toys are a fantastic way to encourage natural hunting instincts while giving your cat a fun dose of exercise. The interactive movement helps stimulate their mind, strengthen your bond, and burn off extra holiday energy (theirs… not yours). Whether it’s feathers, ribbons, or springy wire designs, wand toys keep playtime engaging and safe. One of our favorites: Cat Dancer wand toys — simple, durable, and endlessly entertaining.

Catnip Plush Toys

From gingerbread mice to peppermint-striped plushies, catnip toys bring joy, enrichment, and often a very adorable case of the zooms. In particular, the Yeowww! Brand has catnip-filled toys that enrich the cats playtime. Check them out here: Yeowww! Catnip Toy, Yellow Banana

Puzzle Toys

Perfect for cats who need a little extra mental engagement. Puzzle feeders turn treat time into brain time—and help prevent boredom on long indoor days. They encourage slower eating, reduce overeating, and provide a satisfying challenge that keeps curious cats entertained. Plus, rotating different puzzle styles throughout the week can make mealtime feel new and exciting while supporting your cat’s overall cognitive health. Got a smart kitty? Consider the Catstages by Nina Ottosson Rainy Day Puzzle & Play .

A Quick Safety Reminder About Toys

Many cats love string toys, ribbons, feather attachments, and anything that wiggles or dangles, but these should never be left out when you’re not actively supervising play. Some cats may chew or swallow strings, wire, or fabric, which can lead to dangerous intestinal blockages.

To keep your feline friend safe, always:
• Use wand toys only during supervised play
• Store string-style toys out of reach when you’re done
• Check toys regularly for loose pieces or frayed parts

A few extra precautions go a long way toward keeping holiday fun safe and stress-free for everyone.

5 Pet-Safe Stocking Stuffers for Dogs

Durable Chew Toys

Great for stress relief, healthy chewing habits, and long-lasting engagement. Look for sturdy, vet-approved materials that can handle enthusiastic holiday chomping. Looking to try one out? We recommend KONG brand toys. Check out the Wobbler, which will also dispense treats. It’s a great mental stimulant for your dog.

Rope Toys

Fun for fetch, tug-of-war, and interactive play. Rope toys are durable, festive, and perfect for creating bonding moments with your dog during holiday downtime. Their sturdy woven texture helps clean teeth while your dog chews, making them both entertaining and beneficial for oral health. Plus, they come in all kinds of shapes and holiday colors, adding an extra dash of cheer to your pet’s toy basket. Whether you’re playing indoors on a snowy day or burning energy outside, rope toys are a reliable favorite that bring out your dog’s playful spirit. Our recommendation: Mammoth Flossy Chews Rope Tug

Treat-Dispensing Toys

Puzzle feeders and treat stuffers encourage focus, curiosity, and problem-solving. They’re especially helpful for dogs who thrive on mental enrichment—just like Elizabeth mentioned below! These toys turn mealtime or snack time into a rewarding challenge, helping energetic or anxious dogs channel their enthusiasm in a positive way. By slowing down eating and keeping your dog mentally engaged, puzzle feeders can reduce boredom-related behaviors and make indoor days feel a whole lot more exciting. They’re a simple addition to your routine that delivers big benefits for your dog’s emotional and cognitive well-being. For speedy eaters, consider Outward Hounds Slow Feeder Bowl.

Lick Mats

Dr. Diaphni Taylhardat, one of our Sarasota veterinarians, often recommends lick mats for anxious or high-energy pets. “Lick mats are a simple, effective way to calm dogs and cats while giving them meaningful mental stimulation,” she explains. The repetitive licking action naturally soothes the nervous system and keeps pets focused in a positive way. A favorite option among pet parents is the Lickimat Heavy-Duty Anxiety-Reduction Mat, which is durable enough for enthusiastic lickers and easy to incorporate into daily routines.

Dental Chews

A stocking stuffer that loves back. Dental chews help keep teeth clean, breath fresh, and dogs happily occupied while you’re enjoying cocoa by the tree. They’re a great way to support your dog’s oral health between professional cleanings, and most pups see them as a tasty treat rather than a chore. Plus, the chewing action helps reduce plaque buildup and gives energetic dogs something satisfying to gnaw on during holiday downtime. Our vets recommend: GREENIES Regular Natural Dental Treats, Sweet Potato Flavor

Team Tip:
Elizabeth from our Sarasota location shared, “I recommend KONG toys—the ones that hide treats—for pets that need a lot of brain stimulation.”

Not All Chew Toys Are Safe — What to Avoid

Chewing is a healthy, natural behavior for pets, but not all chew toys are created equal. Some can break teeth, splinter, or become choking or obstruction hazards. When choosing toys for holiday stockings (or anytime), skip these options to keep your pet safe:

Chew Items to Avoid

Cooked Bones
They can splinter easily and cause mouth injuries, choking, or intestinal damage.
Hard Antlers
Extremely hard and known to fracture teeth, especially in enthusiastic chewers.
Hooves
Very hard, can break into sharp pieces, and may cause dental fractures.
Rawhide
Often treated with chemicals and can swell when swallowed, increasing the risk of choking or blockages.
Hard Nylon Bones
While popular, many are rigid enough to crack teeth; always check for softer, flexible alternatives.
Rope Toys (for strong chewers)
If your pet shreds rope, the strands can be ingested, leading to dangerous intestinal obstructions.

What to Look for Instead

Choose toys labeled as:
• Durable but flexible (you should be able to make a slight indent with your fingernail)
• Size-appropriate for your pet
• Made from safe materials like natural rubber, soft silicone, or vet-recommended composites
• Designed for supervised chew sessions

When in doubt, your veterinary team can help guide you toward the safest, most appropriate options for your pet’s size, age, and chewing style.

A Holiday Reminder from Your Veterinary Team

Product recommendations are intended as general guidance. Pet owners should assess each product’s safety and suitability based on their pet’s individual needs. Your veterinary team can provide personalized advice.

Want to stay up to date with us? Give us a follow on Facebook & Instagram.

Here’s to a merry, bright, and pet-safe holiday season! Let us know if you’d like more personalized recommendations for your furry family.

special offer

Enjoy $25 OFF your 1st visit! OR $25 OFF your next visit when you refer a friend!

Enter your email below for offer details. Terms and conditions apply.

Deborah Mitchell, DVM
Veterinarian

Dr. Deborah Mitchell sold Knollwood Hospital for Pets in August 2024 to Hometown Veterinary Partners and is now retired. Dr. Mitchell and her wife, Dr. Heather Hopkins, share their lives with a rescued terrier mix, 14-year-old Walter from Homeward Bound Animal Rescue. In her spare time, Dr. Mitchell enjoys gardening, reading, kayaking, and volunteering with the Greater Chicago Food Depository.

Dazjah Samuels, DVM
Veterinarian

Dr. Dazjah Samuels grew up in the south suburbs of Chicago, where her passion for animals was ignited. She has had an obsession with animals for as long as she can remember, gained from watching her grandmother feed and provide shelter for homeless animals in their neighborhood. After high school, Dr. Samuels traveled to New Orleans, LA to attend Dillard University where she earned a bachelor’s degree in Biology, minoring in Chemistry.

Dr. Samuels is a 2024 graduate from Ross University School of Veterinary Medicine, and attended the University of Minnesota College of Veterinary Medicine for her clinical year. While attending veterinary school, Dr. Samuels became a Morris Animal Foundation and Foundation for Food & Agriculture Research (FFAR) grant recipient for research on bat populations in St. Kitts. Dr. Samuels ’interests include dermatology and surgery, and she plans to incorporate integrative medicine into her everyday practice. She has one dog (Moon) and a guinea pig (Cocoa Butter). Her hobbies include painting, watching tv, and relaxing outside with Moon.

Cindy Makofski (Dr. Mak), DVM
Partner Veterinarian

Dr. Mak, a proud graduate of the University of Illinois College of Veterinary Medicine, completed her internship at Colorado State University Veterinary Hospital. Afterward, she returned to central Illinois, where she cared for a wide range of animals before relocating to the Chicago suburbs to focus on cats and dogs. With years of experience managing multiple hospitals and mentoring new veterinarians, Dr. Mak brings exceptional expertise and leadership to our team.

“I knew from the age of five that I wanted to become a veterinarian, thanks to an encyclopedia about animals my mother gave me. It became my nightly bedtime story.”

Dr. Mak is a dedicated animal lover, having rescued several cats and adopted their beloved dog, Otis. When she’s not in the clinic, she’s an avid Chicago Bears fan, enjoys playing fantasy football with friends, and loves spending time Up North, boating and swimming on Chute Pond.

Dr. Stephanie Ortiz, DVM
Associate Veterinarian

Dr. Stephanie Ortiz completed her veterinary education at Ross University School of Veterinary Medicine, finishing her clinical year at Louisiana State University. She was inspired to become a veterinarian by an impactful experience as a child, when a harsh encounter with a veterinarian left her determined to approach pet care with compassion and education. This experience shaped her philosophy that every pet owner deserves respect and the benefit of the doubt, regardless of their background.

Dr. Ortiz has been practicing veterinary medicine since 2016, primarily working with dogs and cats, and she has a special interest in dentistry, which she continues to enhance through annual wet labs. She emphasizes the importance of preventive care, client communication, and education, striving to ensure that pet owners fully understand the purpose behind recommended treatments.

At home, she has two dogs, John and Ellie, and four cats, who mostly prefer her husband—except for her 16-year-old cat, who occasionally forgets her role as the family veterinarian. Outside of work, Dr. Ortiz enjoys movies, antiquing, and spending time with her dogs. Among her memorable cases is a dog diagnosed with Addison’s disease after his owners noticed he had stopped smiling—a testament to the value of listening to clients’ observations.

Dr. Ortiz stays current with advancements in veterinary medicine through continuing education and looks forward to further improving her dentistry skills. Her advice to pet owners is simple yet reassuring: “You don’t have to be perfect; we do the best we can.”

Dr. Valerie Eisenbart, DVM
Partner Veterinarian

Dr. Valerie Eisenbart completed her veterinary education at the University of Illinois and was inspired to become a veterinarian because of the wide variety of opportunities the field offers. She holds a Master’s in Public Health (MPH) from the University of Illinois at Chicago, in addition to her DVM, and has been practicing veterinary medicine for 13 years.

Dr. Eisenbart has extensive experience with dogs and cats, primarily working in general practice, and has held roles that involved coaching other DVMs. Her approach to veterinary care focuses on providing the best possible care that aligns with her clients’ beliefs and priorities. She emphasizes prevention and monitoring, advocating for an appropriate diet, comprehensive parasite prevention, vaccinations, and dental care to keep pets healthy.

Building strong client relationships is a priority for Dr. Eisenbart, and she does so by listening to her clients’ concerns and understanding the human-animal bond. At home, she has a few fish and a corn snake. Outside of work, she enjoys traveling and spending quality time with her family.

Dr. Eisenbart is actively involved with professional organizations, including the ISVMA, the University of Illinois Veterinary Medical Alumni Association, the AVMA, and the Multicultural Veterinary Medical Association. She was honored as Chief of Staff of the Year in 2019 and received the ISVMA Dr. Erwin Small First Decade Award in 2021.

Her professional goals include creating an inclusive hospital environment and supporting the growth and development of her team and other veterinary professionals. A memorable highlight of her career includes successfully treating parvovirus in two young puppies through outpatient care, watching them grow into healthy young dogs.

Dr. Eisenbart advises pet owners to prioritize dental health, noting that brushing teeth or using dental wipes and scheduling regular cleanings can greatly impact a pet’s overall health. She stays up-to-date with advancements in veterinary medicine by attending conferences and participating in online veterinary communities. Dr. Eisenbart cherishes meeting clients, hearing their stories, and feels privileged to be part of their lives while caring for their beloved pets.

Katie Kuecker
Hospital Director

Katie is a certified veterinary technician who has dedicated the last 19 years of her career to various aspects of veterinary medicine. She has been a Practice manager for the last four years after having completed her business degree.

She has a genuine love for her work and her favorite part is being able to develop strong relationships with clients and their pets. One of her passions is supporting her team and providing them with the necessary resources to grow their careers. She is a compassionate leader who values the importance of building a positive and collaborative work environment.

In her free time, Katie enjoys spending time with her family, playing volleyball, traveling, photography, and taking care of her hobby farm. She shares her life with her beloved horse Turbo, mini donkey Zoey, cat Fergus, and Husky Luke, and is always looking forward to welcoming more animals into her family. Katie’s commitment to her profession, her team, and her family is an inspiration to those around her, and her passion for helping others and animals alike makes her a valuable member of our team and we are so lucky to have her.

Katie Cerulli, DVM
Partner Veterinarian

Dr. Cerulli’s journey in veterinary medicine began in upstate New York before she embarked on an academic adventure. She obtained her Bachelor’s degree in Animal Science, with a minor in Dairy Science, from the University of New Hampshire. Driven by her passion for animals, she pursued her veterinary education at Ross University School of Veterinary Medicine, situated on the picturesque island of St. Kitts in the British West Indies. To complete her training, she conducted her clinical year at Oklahoma State University in Stillwater, OK.

With a solid educational foundation, Dr. Cerulli embarked on her professional career working as a small animal veterinarian in Glastonbury, CT. In November 2021, she relocated to Minnesota, bringing her expertise and warm-hearted approach to her new community.

As a proud pitbull mom to Amaretto and Drambuie, Dr. Cerulli understands the profound bond between pets and their owners. In her leisure time, she cherishes moments spent with loved ones, indulging in board games, unleashing her creativity through crafting, exploring new destinations, embarking on invigorating hikes with her four-legged companions, and capturing memories through her lens as a keen photographer.

Dr. Cerulli’s professional interests extend to behavior and preventative medicine, reflecting her commitment to the holistic well-being of her patients. With genuine enthusiasm, she eagerly looks forward to getting to know you and your beloved pets, delivering compassionate care and forging lasting connections. 💛

Kris
Practice Manager

Kris is the hospital manager and a certified veterinary technician. Kris has been working in the veterinary field since 1985. Kris is the pet parent to two dogs – Spirit, a Westie/Bichon mix and Alice, a beagle/terrier mix. Both Kris’ dogs are rescues.

Dr. Peggy Cerling
Veterinarian

Dr. Peggy Cerling graduated from the University of Illinois in 1990. Dr. Cerling has two daughters and is the pet parent to two cats, Scribbles, and Rosie both domestic shorthairs, a Golden Retriever named Buddy, and a Dutch Warmblood horse, Perry. Dr. Cerling’s cats and dog are rescues.

Dr. Jill Mlsna
Veterinarian

Dr. Jill Mlsna graduated from Michigan State University in 1989. Dr. Mlsna has two daughters and one son and is the pet parent to two dogs, Jayce a labradoodle, Roxy a mix, and two domestic shorthair cats, Nellie and Mosses. All of Dr. Mlsna’s pets are rescues.

Dr. Delaney Rohan
Associate Veterinarian

Dr. Delaney Rohan earned her Doctor of Veterinary Medicine from St. George’s University, completing her clinical year at the University of Minnesota. She also holds a Master’s in Public Health, which shapes her One Health approach to veterinary care — recognizing the deep connection between animal, human, and environmental health.

Her journey into veterinary medicine began at Farm Camp as a child, when an unforgettable hands-on moment with a cow sparked her lifelong passion to advocate for animals.

With over two years of experience working with dogs and cats, Dr. Rohan is passionate about preventative care and enjoys working collaboratively with pet owners to create treatment plans that suit their unique needs.

Outside the clinic, Dr. Rohan enjoys playing volleyball and pickleball, cross-country skiing, biking, and spending time with family and friends. She shares her home with a tabby cat named Jackson and is excited to meet you and your pets!

Dr. Raeyna Longtin, DVM, CVA, FFCP, AAFP-CFV, CAETA-CGEP
Veterinarian

Dr. Longtin has been caring for pets and their people for nearly three decades. A proud graduate of the University of Minnesota College of Veterinary Medicine, she’s built a career rooted in empathy, understanding, and a deep appreciation for the special bond between animals and their families.
With advanced training in veterinary acupuncture, Fear Free handling, feline-friendly care, and gentle euthanasia, Dr. Longtin brings both clinical skills and a calming presence to every visit. She believes great veterinary care starts with listening—understanding not just the pet’s needs, but the unique role that pet plays in the life of their family.

Dr. Longtin spent 12 years as a house call veterinarian, an experience that forever shaped her flexible, patient-focused approach. She understands that there’s no one-size-fits-all solution and works closely with each family to find the care plan that’s right for them.

Outside the clinic, you’ll likely find her working on crafts or fixing up her vintage Volkswagen Beetle. Her home is full of love—and pets! She shares it with a golden retriever named Bubbles, five cats, two snakes, and a tank full of colorful fish.

Whether it’s a routine checkup or a tough decision, Dr. Longtin is here to support you and your pet every step of the way.

Dr. Andrea Braha
Partner Veterinarian

Dr. Andrea Braha is a compassionate and experienced veterinarian specializing in small animal medicine. She earned her Doctor of Veterinary Medicine degree from the Western College of Veterinary Medicine in 2011. Dr. Braha started her veterinary career in Canada before moving to the Tampa Bay area, where she had been proudly serving the community for over a decade.

While enjoying all aspects of veterinary medicine, Dr. Braha’s focus is on emergency and internal medicine. She brings a wealth of expertise to her role, with a background in general practice, urgent care, and 24/7 emergency facilities. Dr. Braha is dedicated to offering a concierge level of medical service, tailoring personalized care to meet the unique needs of each pet and their family. She constantly strives to hone her skills through hands-on courses and continuing education, staying at the forefront of veterinary advancements.

When she’s not in the clinic, Dr. Braha enjoys spending time outdoors with her Great Pyrenees, competing in local horse shows, traveling and experiencing new regions, and exploring the vibrant lifestyle of sunny Florida.

Dr. Rob Nicholson
Partner Doctor

Dr. Rob Nicholson graduated from Tufts Veterinary School in 1995. He has practiced both large and small animal medicine in the area for the past 20 years. In addition to currently being a small animal Veterinarian, he is an Associate Clinical Professor at Tufts Veterinary School, teaching the Clinical Skills course to first and second-year Veterinary students.

Dr. Nicholson enjoys preventive medicine, surgery, and dentistry and is enjoying serving the greater Charlton area as the new owner of Post Road Veterinary Hospital.

Dr. Jennifer Fagerquist
Associate Veterinarian

Dr. Jennifer Fagerquist grew up in Charlton. She received her Bachelor of Science degree from the University of Massachusetts Amherst and her Veterinary Degree from Purdue University School of Veterinary Medicine.

Dr. Fagerquist completed 100 hours of coursework at CHI institute in 2013 for Veterinary Acupuncture.
She shares her home with her husband, 6 wonderful children and 2 dogs – Trixie and Tilly along with chickens, ducks, turkeys, geese and donkeys!

In her spare time, Dr. Fagerquist enjoys being outdoors, photography, cooking and decorating cakes. She loves gardening and Cross Fit.

Her love language is acts of service, and it brings her great joy to cook and craft for the team members!

Brandi Obman
Hospital Director

Brandi’s passion for creating a collaborative and healthy work environment where everyone feels welcome and supported aligns perfectly with our vision to create positive change in veterinary medicine. Brandi says, “I’m excited to make a hospital space that makes sense for the people working in it. I see this as an opportunity to show our teams that there is a way to get back to why we started in veterinary medicine in the first place.”

Fun facts about Brandi:

She is originally from Chicago and lives in South Carolina
Her favorite food is Alaskan Snow Crab (in large quantities, of course!)
She has two cats, Tuna Tataki and Wasabi Ginger and four chickens, Pad, Thai, Stepanie, and HeiHei
She is a graduate of Coastal Carolina University with a BS in Marine Science
She has 16 years of experience in veterinary medicine as a VA and Practice Manager

Kathleen Chiu (Hayes), DVM (aka “Q”)
Partner Veterinarian

Originally from Massachusetts, Dr. Chiu’s journey started with a childhood obsession with any critter she could get her hands on. From her beloved family cat Pumpkin to the mischievous duo Toby and Rusty, she adored all things fluffy. No wonder she developed a passion for veterinary medicine! Her academic endeavors took her from the University of Vermont, where she majored in Animal Science and Biological Science (think herding cows and being a livestock management pro!), to The Royal (Dick) School of Veterinary Studies at The University of Edinburgh. Graduating with Distinction in 2011, she proved she was no ordinary vet—she was a force to be reckoned with. Q is always on a mission to expand her knowledge, so she’s currently enrolling at Chi University for Certification in Veterinary Acupuncture.

When it comes to her professional interests, Dr. Chiu’s passions lie in preventative health, internal medicine, endocrinology, chronic pain management, and alternative medicine. She has her own fantastic crew of pets, including two Pitbulls, Casey, and Asher, who were rescued from dog fighting. There’s Kiwi and Phoebe, their indoor kitties, and a gang of rescue barn cats named Strip, Fifty, and Ghost. And let’s not forget “The Fantastic Four,” their feathery friends that rule the backyard—the chickens!

Dr. Chiu enjoys quality time with her family, getting her hands dirty in the garden, whipping up some mouthwatering treats in the kitchen, and embracing the beach life. Moving to the Myrtle Beach area was the ultimate game-changer for her, offering the perfect blend of work and play. She’s all about saving the day for the Myrtle Beach community’s furry companions and supporting local pet and wildlife rescues. She’s here to be their champion and their dedicated vet!